A key goal of any retirement planning approach is to save for retirement in a tax-efficient manner. Individual retirement accounts (IRAs) are a well-known mechanism for achieving this goal in the United States. Traditional plans, in which the account is started with pre-tax dollars and distributions are taxed, or Roth plans, in which the account is funded with after-tax dollars and payouts are tax-free, are available.

An IRA must be a trust or a custodial account founded or organized in the United States for the sole benefit of an individual or the individual’s beneficiaries, according to US tax laws.

Written instructions must govern the account, and it must meet certain rules for donations, distributions, holdings, and the identification of the trustee or custodian. The custodian’s criteria and limits, as well as the account’s permissible holdings, give rise to a unique sort of IRA: the self-directed IRA (SDIRA).


IMPORTANT: A self-directed IRA is an alternative retirement account managed by a financial institution in which the account owner can invest in alternative investments and direct them themselves.

Real estate, precious metals, mortgages, and private equity are all possible assets in a self-directed IRA, as long as the investments don’t violate tax restrictions.

This IRA varies from a traditional IRA in that the custodian chooses which investments a member can own and often chooses highly liquid, easily priced products like equities, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs.

Self-Managed vs. Self-Directed Individual Retirement Arrangements

Self-Directed IRA rules

Account owners in all IRAs can choose from the investment possibilities permitted by the IRA trust agreement and buy and sell those investments at their discretion, as long as the sale proceeds remain in the account. Because IRA custodians are permitted to choose the types of assets they will manage within the limits specified by tax legislation, investors are limited in their options. Most IRA custodians only accept investments in products that are highly liquid and easily priced, such as approved equities, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, and CDs.

Certain custodians, on the other hand, are willing to run accounts including alternative assets and to provide the account owner extensive influence over those investments, subject to tax authorities’ prohibitions. Only a few IRS limitations against illiquid or unlawful operations and the willingness of a custodian to administer the holding limit the choice of alternative investments.4

Direct real estate ownership, which could include rental property or a redevelopment situation, is the most commonly mentioned example of an SDIRA alternative investment.

Compared to publicly traded REIT assets, which are often available through more traditional IRA accounts, direct real-estate ownership is more affordable. Small-business shares, LLC interests, precious metals, mortgages, partnerships, private equity, and tax liens are all common examples.

SDIRAs are riskier for investors than traditional IRAs, and are best suited to people who have in-depth knowledge of a certain market segment and can thus outperform the market.

The Benefits and Drawbacks of a Self-Directed IRA

The benefits of an SDIRA are related to the account owner’s capacity to acquire alpha in a tax-advantaged manner by using alternative investments. The greater risk levels associated with alternative investments, as well as the regulatory expenses and dangers related to an SDIRA, are all disadvantages. Success in an SDIRA ultimately hinges on the account owner’s particular knowledge or ability in capturing returns that, after risk adjustment, outperform the market.

Regulatory Obligations and Obstacles

Self-dealing, in which the IRA owner or other designated individuals utilize the account for personal gain or to violate the intent of the tax law, is forbidden. The identification of disqualified people and the types of transactions these people may not initiate with the account are key parts of SDIRA regulation and compliance. Violations of prohibited transaction rules can have serious consequences, such as the IRS declaring the entire IRA taxable at market value as of the beginning of the year in which the prohibited transaction occurred, exposing the taxpayer to previously deferred taxes and a 10% early withdrawal penalty.5

A “disqualified person,” according to the IRS, is anyone who has control over the assets, revenues, disbursements, and investments, or who has the ability to influence investment decisions. IRA account fiduciaries, the IRA owner’s spouse, lineal descendants, and lineal descendants’ spouses are all on this list. 5

There are far too many specific examples of forbidden transactions to list, but there are some general guidelines. The IRA cannot be used to buy stock or other assets from an ineligible person, lease assets from or to a disqualified person, buy stock in a firm in which a disqualified person owns a controlling interest, or lend to or borrow from a disqualified person, to name a few examples.

With $100,000 in virtual cash, you may compete without risk.

Use our FREE Stock Simulator to put your trading talents to the test. Compete against hundreds of other traders on Investopedia and trade your way to the top! Before you start risking your own money, practice trading in a simulated environment. Practice trading tactics so that you’ll be prepared to enter the real market when the time comes.